- Lawyers for Vernon Unsworth, the British cave diver suing Elon Musk for defamation after Musk called him a "pedo guy," unveiled new documents in the lawsuit on Monday.
- The documents contain an email from Musk to a PR agent where he calls himself a "f–king idiot" for telling a BuzzFeed journalist Unsworth was a "child rapist" in an email.
- Unsworth's lawyers allege Musk not only paid a PI to dig up dirt on Unsworth, but also to feed information to the British press.
- The documents reveal how Musk came to deeply regret his extraordinary allegations against the cave diver.
- Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.
Elon Musk has privately admitted he was a "f–king idiot" for calling a cave diver a "child rapist" in an email to a journalist.
Court documents made public Monday night in a legal battle between cave diver Vernon Unsworth and the Tesla CEO have shed more light on the fallout from Musk's evidence-free allegation on Twitter that Unsworth is a "pedo guy."
Musk first tweeted calling Unsworth "pedo guy" in July last year, after the professional diver had criticised Musk's proposal to rescue a Thai soccer team trapped in a flooded cave in Thailand using a submarine — a move Unsworth described as a publicity stunt.
The following month, after receiving an email from BuzzFeed News reporter Ryan Mac, the 48-year-old tech executive emailed the journalist with a barrage of fresh allegations, claiming (without offering evidence) that Unsworth is a "child rapist" who married a 12-year-old, and urging Mac to investigate. Mac subsequently published the email, which Musk had prefaced with "off the record" (Mac had not agreed to an off-the-record exchange in advance).
The new court documents from Unsworth's lawyers include emails Musk sent to a PR agent after the debacle, revealing how he came to regret his extraordinary allegations against the cave diver. "I didn't expect Buzzfeed to publish an off the record email. My intent was to have them investigate and come to their own conclusions, not publish my email directly. Still, I'm a f–king idiot," Musk wrote.
"In the past, Buzzfeed has respected emails prefaced with 'off the record,' but this time they did not. It was still one of the dumbest things I've ever done," he added.
Unsworth's lawyers allege that Musk and Mac's interaction was not the only example of the CEO trying to feed stories to the press about Unsworth.
A private eye hired by Musk to dig into Unsworth, James Howard-Higgins, was also tasked with feeding information surreptitiously back to the press, the new documents indicate. An email to Howard-Higgins from the head of Musk's family office, Jared Birchall, said: "We would like you to immediately move forward with 'leaking' this information to the UK press. Obviously must be done very carefully."
A previous set of documents in the case first revealed that Musk had hired Howard-Higgins to defend himself, and BuzzFeed subsequently reported last week that Howard-Higgins has a history of fraud. In a deposition, Musk said he realised the reports he was sending back to Musk's family office were "just taking us for a ride."
Unsworth's UK lawyer Mark Stephens alleged to Business Insider that Musk's email to BuzzFeed News and Howard-Higgins' instructions to leak to the press show a common attempt to manipulate the media without explicitly naming Musk as the source of the information. "It's exactly the same strategy," he said.
Unsworth's lawyers also claim that Howard-Higgins never gave Musk any information about Unsworth marrying a twelve-year-old. "Nothing in [Howard-Higgins'] report would reflect or give grounds to say that," said Stephens.